Menu
© 2026 World Compliance Association

04/02/2026

Court orders a Renfe subsidiary to pay 15,000 euros in compensation to a worker who was dismissed in retaliation

Unlike his colleagues, the employee was not transferred as part of the process of bringing the service in-house – which was taken over by Logirail – and was made redundant by the outgoing company.

Court orders a Renfe subsidiary to pay 15,000 euros in compensation to a worker who was dismissed in retaliation

Bartolomé (not his real name) worked as a ticket office assistant for Mitie, providing customer service for Renfe. When the state-owned railway company decided to bring this service in-house through direct management by its subsidiary Logirail, this employee, unlike his colleagues, was not transferred to the new arrangement but was instead made redundant in June 2021 by the outgoing company. This was despite him having been successful in the selection process organised by Renfe’s services subsidiary.

At first instance, Bilbao Labour Court No. 7 ruled that the dismissal was unfair, but it was a subsequent ruling by the High Court of Justice of the Basque Country that declared the dismissal by MITIE null and void, on the grounds that the decision constituted retaliation because the worker had previously protested against two disciplinary measures imposed by the company, which were subsequently reduced. Furthermore, it ordered Logirail to reinstate him and pay him his outstanding wages.

Logirail lodged an appeal on points of law with the Supreme Court, which in September 2025 quashed the judgement and ordered the High Court of Justice of the Basque Country to review the case in order to “address the arguments set out in the statement challenging the appeal lodged by Logirail and rule on the review of the facts requested”. 

This regional court, in a recent ruling to which this publication has had access, has not only confirmed the invalidity of the dismissal, with an obligation to reinstate the employee immediately and pay the wages in arrears, but has also ordered the Renfe subsidiary to pay the worker compensation of 15,000 euros. 

The employee expressly requested a declaration that the dismissal was null and void on the grounds of a breach of the fundamental right to effective judicial protection, specifically the guarantee of compensation, as the reason he was not transferred following the in-house take-over of the ground handling service was “the employee’s reaction to two previous disciplinary measures”, according to the judgement handed down on 9 December.

The First Section of the Labour Chamber criticises the first-instance ruling for “suffering from a clear lack of reasoning”, as “it fails to explain why the aforementioned infringement of those rights does not occur in the present case, nor does it set out whether or not there are indications of a breach of those fundamental rights, nor whether the company has complied with the special allocation of the burden of proof imposed on it by Article 181.2 of the Labour Relations Act (LRJS), when it should have done so in order to respond to the claim for a declaration of the nullity of the dismissal based on the allegation of specific facts (previous disciplinary measures, the employee’s reaction to them, etc.), details which are also not reflected in the statement of facts”.

Consequently, the court considers that the employee has been left without a proper defence, in that he receives only an “unfounded” response, failing to provide the legal arguments that would address his legitimate claim, and this constitutes a breach of the right to effective judicial protection”.

The only eligible employee outside the subrogation process

The Employment Chamber maintains that the factual account also contains “no reason for this differential treatment of the claimant employee”, although there are “certain events occurring around the same time which constitute clear indications that his guarantee of immunity has been breached”, a fundamental right that protects any worker from adverse consequences arising from any claim they may make.

In this regard, the court points out that “in this case, it was incumbent upon the company to prove the reasons for its conduct that were unrelated to that unconstitutional motive”. In its statement of defence, Logirail argued that it “did not take on all existing staff” at the company because “it had to respect budgetary constraints on staff recruitment”, and denied any breach of the guarantee of indemnity, since the termination of the contract did not occur exclusively in relation to the appellant but as part of a collective process of contract terminations. 

The subsidiary also argued that the dismissal was not an act of retaliation against the employee and emphasised that, in this case, it was the company MITIE that had disciplined him, “without Logirail having been informed of those disciplinary measures or of the complaints lodged by the employee”.

However, the court determined that these circumstances are not recorded in the statement of facts, “nor could they have been introduced, nor would they undermine the evidence of conduct in breach” of the guarantee of indemnity. The fact is that, as set out in the established facts, “at least at the claimant’s workplace, the only employee who was not called upon to continue providing services following the selection process, despite having been declared fit for work, was the claimant, without the company having justified why the person selected for exclusion was precisely the one with a history of appeals against two previous sanctions, which, moreover, were reduced in both cases, either by mutual agreement or by a court judgement”, the judgement emphasises.

It also sets the amount of compensation at 15,000 euros, which falls within the range applicable to very serious breaches of the regulations cited by the claimant as a guideline, “it fulfils, in a proportionate manner, the remedial and preventive functions of averting further infringements of the fundamental right” and is “consistent” with previous rulings of this court.

The new judgement of the High Court of Justice of the Basque Country is not final and is subject to an appeal on points of law for the unification of doctrine before the Labour Chamber of the Supreme Court.

Source: https://www.publico.es/

NEWS LINK

reCAPTCHA protection