Menu
© 2026 World Compliance Association

17/04/2026

The National High Court is sending a clear message: compliance must work in practice. Lessons from Order AAN 730/2026

The National High Court is sending a clear message: compliance must work in practice. Lessons from Order AAN 730/2026

By Iván Martínez, CEO of Intedya

The recent ruling by the National High Court (Order 114/2026) sets out one of the most significant rulings to date on the criminal liability of legal persons in Spain. Beyond the specific case, the ruling establishes a clear criterion: it is not enough simply to have a compliance system; it is essential that it works, particularly where the greatest risk lies: senior management. The Chamber has confirmed that criminal proceedings against the organisation are to continue, having found that there is sufficient evidence to suggest that the crime prevention model was not effective, despite the formal existence of policies, controls and certifications.

From formal compliance to effective compliance

One of the most significant aspects of the ruling is the implicit yet forceful distinction between formal compliance and effective compliance. The court does not question the existence of internal rules, codes of ethics or even structured prevention models. What it does question is their actual capacity to prevent, detect and respond to unlawful conduct. In this regard, the ruling debunks a belief still widespread in many organisations: that the documentary implementation of a system (including certifications such as UNE 19601) is sufficient to mitigate criminal risks. The National High Court asserts the opposite: the analysis is substantive, not formal.

The critical point: senior management outside the system

The core of the court’s reasoning is particularly relevant for any compliance professional: in practice, the control system excluded the Executive Chairman and senior management; this factor is decisive. From the perspective of Article 31 bis of the Criminal Code, the liability of a legal person does not stem solely from the commission of offences by natural persons, but from organisational failure to prevent them. When the system itself, explicitly or implicitly, excludes those with the greatest decision-making power, the model ceases to be a control mechanism and becomes a purely decorative instrument.

The ‘culture of obedience’ versus the ‘culture of compliance’

The ruling introduces a concept of great doctrinal value: the transition from a culture of compliance to a culture of obedience. This finding reflects a well-known organisational pathology in high-risk environments:

  • The rules exist

  • Employees are aware of them

  • But they are not applied when they conflict with decisions made by senior management

The result is an organisation where compliance is selective and hierarchically conditioned. From a compliance perspective, this implies a systemic failure in:

  • the ‘tone at the top’

  • the independence of control functions

  • the ability to escalate issues and make complaints

Controls designed to be circumvented

Another critical aspect of the case is the identification of mechanisms that allowed internal controls to be circumvented without the need for sophisticated fraud. The report describes practices such as:

  • classifying suppliers as creditors to circumvent procurement controls

  • contracting without formal procedures

  • lack of third-party approval

  • payment channels outside standard traceability

These practices do not stem from isolated failures, but from structural weaknesses in the control system. From a compliance perspective, this leads to a clear conclusion: a system is ineffective not only when it fails, but also when it can be easily circumvented by design.

The failure of the whistleblowing channel

The judgement also addresses a common feature of compliance models: the whistleblowing channel. Although it formally existed, the court notes:

  • a lack of evidence regarding its operation during critical periods

  • no alerts despite the existence of multiple internal indications

  • employees’ awareness of irregularities without the channel being activated

This reveals a recurring problem: whistleblowing channels exist, but they do not inspire confidence or provide effective protection. In terms of management systems, this represents a failure in both design and organisational culture.

The irrelevance of certification in the absence of effectiveness

One of the most forceful messages in the ruling is the relativisation of the value of external certifications. The fact that the organisation held certification in criminal compliance does not prevent the court from questioning the actual effectiveness of the system.

This sends a clear warning to the market:

  • Certification is a starting point

  • It is not, in itself, a defence

What matters is whether the model prevents, detects and responds.

Detectability versus concealment: a key criterion

The court emphasises that the conduct under investigation was:

  • of a prolonged nature

  • visible across multiple areas

  • detectable through basic controls

This is particularly relevant because it shifts the focus away from the sophistication of the fraud and towards the organisation’s ability to detect it. In other words, the system is not required to be infallible, but it must be reasonably effective.

Conclusion: the new standard for criminal compliance

AAN Order 730/2026 establishes a rigorous yet realistic standard for criminal compliance in Spain.

The main conclusions are clear:

  • A system that does not monitor senior management is, by definition, ineffective

  • Organisational culture is just as important as the technical design of the model

  • Traceability and operational controls are crucial

  • Certification is no substitute for effectiveness; whilst it provides a good starting point, it is insufficient if its implementation is not comprehensive and effective.

  • The detectability of conduct is a key assessment criterion

Ultimately, the court does not assess whether compliance exists, but whether it works where it is most needed. And that is, probably, the greatest challenge facing organisations today.

 

reCAPTCHA protection