Menu
© 2026 World Compliance Association

15/08/2026

Digital disconnection and workplace compliance: another summer with our homework still undone

Since the Organic Law on Data Protection and the Guarantee of Digital Rights came into force in 2018, failure to comply with the obligation to draw up an opt-out protocol remains conspicuous by its absence in many companies

Digital disconnection and workplace compliance: another summer with our homework still undone

When it comes to workplace compliance, one of the main areas of non-compliance in many companies is the obligation to draw up and implement a digital disconnection policy; and when the summer period arrives, this issue repeatedly comes back onto the agenda.

All companies (regardless of the number of employees on their payroll) are obliged to draw up and implement a digital disconnection protocol or policy, pursuant to Article 88 of the Organic Law on Data Protection and the Guarantee of Digital Rights. However, almost eight years after the Act came into force (on 7 December 2018), this obligation is conspicuous by its absence.

Furthermore, when it comes to fulfilling obligations relating to the exercise of the right to digital disconnection, it is essential that companies take into account not only the area of labour compliance, but also occupational risk prevention and strategic people management policies. Factors such as whether or not the company has a work-life balance policy; flexible working hours; a clear corporate policy on the use of company devices; whether or not there are instances of regular remote working (30 per cent as stipulated in Law 10/2021 on remote working); and whether employees, clients, suppliers, etc. are based in countries with different time zones, all play a decisive role in establishing an ad hoc protocol that truly reflects the reality of each company.

The 3 key factors companies need to be aware of

Regardless of what the applicable collective agreement may stipulate (there are an increasing number of collective agreements regulating this issue, with varying degrees of specificity), this is what companies and employees need to know about the right to digital disconnection.

1. Current regulation of the right to digital disconnection

The right to digital disconnection has been expressly regulated since 2018 under Article 88 of the Organic Law on Data Protection and the Guarantee of Digital Rights (LOPDGDD), which states the following:

Article 88. The right to digital disconnection in the workplace.

  1. Workers and public-sector employees shall have the right to digital disconnection in order to ensure, outside statutory or contractually agreed working hours, respect for their rest periods, leave and holidays, as well as their personal and family privacy.
  2. The arrangements for exercising this right shall take into account the nature and purpose of the employment relationship, shall promote the right to a work-life balance, and shall be subject to the provisions of collective bargaining agreements or, failing that, to what has been agreed between the employer and the workers’ representatives.
  3. The employer, after consulting with workers’ representatives, shall draw up an internal policy addressed to workers, including those in managerial positions, setting out the arrangements for exercising the right to disconnect and the training and awareness-raising measures for staff on the reasonable use of technological tools to avoid the risk of digital fatigue.

In particular, the right to digital disconnection shall be safeguarded in cases where work is carried out wholly or partly remotely, as well as at the employee’s home where technological tools are used for work purposes.

2. What are companies’ obligations?

All companies, regardless of their workforce size or sector of activity, are obliged to draw up a protocol (internal policy) on digital disconnection.

Furthermore, drawing up a digital disconnection protocol is mandatory regardless of whether or not the company has cases of remote working. However, if the company has cases of regular remote working, the provisions of Article 18 of Law 10/2021 on remote working must also be taken into account.

The obligation is to draw up and implement the digital disconnection protocol; furthermore, should the need arise (in the event of an inspection and/or court proceedings), the company must be able to demonstrate not only that it has a protocol, but also that this protocol or policy has been expressly communicated to the workforce and that employees are aware of the protocol, its content and the measures it contains.

Furthermore, the training and awareness-raising measures required by law must be complied with (although Article 88 of the LOPDGDD does not specify the number, nature or frequency of such measures, and collective agreements do not, generally speaking, address this specific issue either).

3. Penalties for breaching the right to digital disconnection

At present, there is no specific type of penalty for breaching the right to digital disconnection. However, the violation of the right to digital disconnection is classified as a serious offence (Article 7.5 of the LISOS): ‘The breach of legal or agreed rules and limits regarding working hours, night work, overtime, compensatory time off, rest periods, holidays, leave, recording of working hours and, in general, the working time referred to in Articles 12, 23 and 34 to 38 of the Workers’ Statute’.

Serious infringements are punishable by a fine of between 751 and 7,500 euros.

Furthermore, failure to comply with obligations regarding the right to digital disconnection could be considered a breach of health and safety regulations and, in (in the most serious cases) be understood to constitute a form of psychological harassment (e.g. if the company’s practice of calling and/or contacting the worker on a regular and recurring basis outside their working hours is repeated and widespread).

As for holidays, given the special protection (both under Spanish law and as derived from the case law of the CJEU) afforded to the right to holidays, breaching the right to digital disconnection during the holiday period is a more serious matter that could result in onerous consequences for companies.

The landmark ruling of the Supreme Court of 11 November 2025

The Supreme Court has expressly ruled on the right to digital disconnection and on the scope of the obligations that must be fulfilled when a company has a Works Council (legal representatives of the workers).

The digital disconnection protocol is mandatory, but when it comes to drawing it up, the regulations only require that workers’ representatives be given the opportunity to be heard beforehand; they do not impose an obligation to negotiate the digital disconnection protocol with them (Supreme Court ruling of 11 November 2025).

In its judgement, the Supreme Court dismissed the trade union’s appeal. With specific regard to the right to digital disconnection, the legislation only imposes an obligation to consult in advance, but not to negotiate. The Supreme Court specifically sets out the following reasoning regarding digital disconnection:

  • The first point is that the provision of the LOPDGDD (Article 88, which regulates the right to digital disconnection) unequivocally requires that digital disconnection within the company be subject to the relevant provisions of collective bargaining agreements. In the specific case under consideration, the Consultancy and Market Research Collective Agreement applies.
  • Secondly, the company, after consulting the workers’ legal representatives, shall draw up an internal policy addressed to workers – in particular, those working remotely – which defines the arrangements for exercising the right to disconnect; this policy must, without doubt, comply with legal and collective agreement requirements.
  • Finally, the third conclusion stems from the collective agreement provision whose breach is alleged, which stipulates that the right to digital disconnection shall be exercised in accordance with the terms established by law and in line with the policies in place at each company.

In the specific case under consideration, the company’s policies on digital disconnection were established following consultation with and a hearing of the workers’ legal representatives; therefore, there is no evidence of illegality, nor is there any indication of a hypothetical infringement of the appellant’s right to freedom of association, as there is no record that he has been deprived of his right to collective bargaining. For all these reasons, the trade union’s appeal is dismissed.

Assessment: In my view, this is a particularly significant judgement because it makes it clear that the law only requires compliance with the prior consultation procedure, but not negotiation with the workers’ legal representatives – an issue on which there had been considerable uncertainty.

Factors influencing non-compliance with obligations

There are various reasons why companies are failing to comply with the obligation to draw up and implement their digital disconnection protocol, but the main ones are as follows:

  • Lack of awareness of the regulation (particularly among micro-SMEs), despite the fact that almost eight years have now passed since it came into force.
  • A lack of an established or properly implemented culture of work-life balance in many organisations.
  • A ‘presentism’ leadership style that is still deeply ingrained in many Spanish companies.
  • Failure to comply with the obligation to keep a daily record of working hours. In companies that fail to comply with the obligation to keep a daily record of working hours, there is a much greater risk of infringing the right to digital disconnection (apart from other issues such as overtime worked but not paid or not compensated with time off).
  • The perception (albeit mistaken) that the Labour Inspectorate is not imposing penalties for failing to draw up the ‘digital disconnection’ protocol.
  • Using the fact that the applicable collective agreement does not yet regulate this matter as an excuse (in any case, this does not justify failing to draw up the digital disconnection protocol, and, moreover, an increasing number of collective agreements are now regulating this issue).
  • Believing (erroneously) that if there are no instances of remote working within the company, there is no obligation to draw up a digital disconnection protocol.

In any case, it is essential that companies recognise the importance of labour compliance regarding the exercise of the right to digital disconnection and address the disconnection protocol both from a legal and labour perspective and from the viewpoint of strategic people management policies.

Source: Digital disconnection and labour compliance: another summer with our homework undone | E&J

reCAPTCHA protection