Menu
© 2026 World Compliance Association

25/09/2026

Interview with Fernando Osuna Martínez-Boné, Partner specialising in Economic Crime & Compliance at Bufete Osuna

Osuna Legal & Compliance is a gold sponsor of Compliance 360º Andalucía

Interview with Fernando Osuna Martínez-Boné, Partner specialising in Economic Crime & Compliance at Bufete Osuna

On 22 October, the Auditorium of the Faculty of Tourism and Finance at the University of Seville will host Compliance 360º Andalucía: People, Technology and Critical Decisions, the conference with which the World Compliance Association is celebrating its 10th anniversary in the region. Osuna Legal & Compliance is once again a sponsor, this time at gold level. 

Fernando Osuna Martínez-Boné, Partner specialising in Economic Criminal Law & Compliance at Osuna Law Firm, will moderate one of the panel discussions that promises to generate the most debate: “Mistakes in internal investigations: What is being done wrong? What are the limits?”, featuring Fernando Soto (Deputy Prosecutor for Anti-Corruption and Organised Crime), Pedro González (Criminal Law Partner at Garrigues) and Pedro Colina (Head of the Economic Criminal Law Department at Kepler-Karst Law Firm). 

We spoke to him about the mistakes that can compromise an internal investigation from the outset, the boundaries an organisation must not cross, and what happens when the investigation itself ends up becoming a risk.

1. You’re sponsoring the event again, this time as a gold sponsor. Last year you spoke to us about the importance of lawyers ‘getting out of the office’. Does this upgrade from silver to gold also reflect that commitment to staying close to the sector, understanding what concerns clients and anticipating their needs?

Exactly, and with even greater reason. A firm that sits waiting in the office does not grow. But getting out into the world isn’t just about networking: it’s about sitting down with the client and understanding what concerns them, how they think and what keeps them awake at night. It is that closeness that enables us to offer truly useful advice. Moving from silver to gold is taking another step in that direction: being where the conversation on compliance in Andalusia is taking place, rather than reading about it afterwards in a press release.

2. The panel you’re chairing is called: ‘Mistakes in internal investigations: What’s being done wrong? What are the limits?’. When you’re called in once the problem’s already on their hands, what’s the first thing you spot that’s been done wrong, even before you arrive?

That they start investigating before they think. The company reacts in the heat of the moment, wants to resolve it that very afternoon, and makes three or four decisions that subsequently cannot be undone. By the time they call us, the mistake has often already been made. Our first job isn’t to investigate: it’s to put the brakes on.

3. A complaint comes in and management wants to act immediately: check the employee’s email, seize their computer, speak to them that very afternoon. Which of these actions could turn into an irreversible mistake?

Almost anything that sounds like ‘act now’. Accessing the employee’s computer without legal authorisation, speaking to them before anything is clear, sending an email to half the workforce asking what they know. Each of these actions, if handled incorrectly, compromises the evidence or gives rise to a separate legal dispute. And what is damaged in those first few hours usually cannot be repaired.

4. In an internal investigation, the organisation needs access to certain information to establish the facts, but it cannot do so in just any way. What legal boundaries must it be clear about before acting, and where does the risk lie that the investigation itself could give rise to new liability for the organisation? 

Conducting an investigation does not mean that everything is permitted. Can I access an employee’s computer? It depends. Could I commit the offence of disclosing confidential information whilst investigating an alleged offence? Absolutely, if I do so without the necessary safeguards. There is a line to be drawn: privacy, confidentiality of communications, and the dignity of the person under investigation. And however serious the suspicion may be, that line must not be crossed, because the day you cross it, your evidence becomes invalid and the problem becomes yours.

5. And what if the problem lies with the company itself? The Compliance Officer uncovers a crime that implicates not only the employee but also the organisation that pays them. Should they report it, keep quiet, or cover it up? How do you navigate this without making a mistake?

It is the most uncomfortable question of all. The Compliance Officer uncovers something that implicates not only the employee but also the organisation itself. There is no easy answer here, but there is a correct one. The Compliance Officer uncovers something that implicates not only the employee but also the very company that pays them. So what now? Report it? Keep quiet? Cover it up? Well then: the Compliance Officer is not there to protect those who commit offences within the company; they are there to protect the company from itself. Anyone who gets this the wrong way round ends up facing charges.

6. We demand that the Compliance Officer investigate and act correctly, but they may end up facing charges even whilst trying to do the right thing. Aren’t we asking them for a level of legal certainty that the current framework for internal investigations does not provide?

In part, yes, we are asking for that. We do not have a law that clearly sets out the limits of an internal investigation. We work with scattered case law and a great deal of procedural common sense. Is it possible to investigate with legal certainty? With a good procedural lawyer by your side, yes. If you’re winging it, it’s a lottery. And in criminal matters, the lottery is an expensive one. 

7. The Anti-Corruption Prosecutor’s Office sits at your table. What do you think a prosecutor sees in poorly conducted internal investigations that companies would rather not look at?

That’s for him to answer, but in my experience, what a prosecutor sees is that many internal investigations are carried out to reassure the board, not to uncover the truth. A prosecutor can immediately smell a report that’s been cobbled together just to be filed away. And that’s where the company makes two mistakes: it doesn’t solve the problem, and on top of that, it loses the credibility it would have gained by doing it properly. The Public Prosecutor’s Office values those who genuinely cooperate, not those who merely go through the motions.

8. If an organisation listens to you on the 22nd and thinks, ‘I’ve no idea if I’m doing this right’, where would you tell them to start?

Start with the basics: have the phone number of a good litigation lawyer before you need it, not after. And a proper plan for what to do before, during and after a complaint is made. It sounds obvious, but very few companies have one. On the 22nd, we’re going to delve into precisely that detail, using real-life cases and with the Public Prosecutor’s Office present – which is no small matter.

reCAPTCHA protection