Menu
© 2026 World Compliance Association

29/10/2026

Banks are facing a bill running into millions as they have to refund money to customers who have fallen victim to fraud

Financial institutions will have to refund the money from unauthorised transactions within 24 hours and then take legal action if they wish to recover it. Fraud in Europe amounts to 4.2 billion annually.

Banks are facing a bill running into millions as they have to refund money to customers who have fallen victim to fraud

The customer is always right, even in matters relating to bank fraud. Theto disputes between banks and victims of fraud, even where the victims have been grossly negligent – such as writing their PIN on their credit card, giving out a one-off code over the phone, or installing a remote-control app on their computer at the request of a stranger. From now on, financial institutions will not be able to use this as a reason to refuse to refund the money, as they have done until now, according to a recent ruling by the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU). Banks will have to claim the money back from the customer retrospectively.

The ruling opens up a financial challenge for the sector, both in terms of and past claims that may still be reopened. The total value of fraud in the European Economic Area (the 27 EU Member States, plus Iceland, Liechtenstein and Norway) reached 4.2 billion, with over 300 million in Spain alone in 2024, according to the latest data from the European Central Bank (ECB), the European Banking Authority (EBA) and the Bank of Spain.

The potential cost to Spanish banks could be close to 1,000 million, according to industry sources, due to claims dating back up to five years. It will not reach the level of refunds for floor clauses (2,300 million euros). “The sum is very significant, and it hurts the bottom line of financial institutions’ profit and loss accounts,” explains a financial source familiar with the procedure. And this, moreover, has a major impact looking ahead. “They have to bear in mind that they will have to replenish that money immediately,” they add.

So far, the banks have tried to shirk their responsibilities and, in fact, 80 per cent of the costs of fraud involving bank transfers are borne by the customer. For card transactions, the banks cover almost 60 per cent, whilst for cash withdrawals, the liability is shared almost equally. The latest report from the ECB and the EBA reveals that bank transfers top the list of methods used to defraud customers (€153 million), followed by card payments (€141 million) and cash withdrawals (€17 million). The remainder is split between direct debits and electronic money transactions.

Across the European Economic Area as a whole, the in 2024 represents a 17 per cent increase on the previous year. Of this amount, 61 per cent related to transfers and 31 per cent to cards. Users bore the brunt of the losses, with nearly 2,500 million, compared with the 830 million borne by financial institutions and the 450 million borne by other parties involved (primarily technology platforms). The European Court has set a legal precedent, and there is now no doubt that the financial institution must refund the money to the customer without delay, at a time when the number of scams is on the rise, alongside the amount defrauded. In cases where there are suspicions of fraud committed by the customer themselves, the bank must subsequently reclaim the money.

The ruling comes at a time when scams are becoming increasingly sophisticated. The , noting that the average amount of fraudulent transfers rose by 42 per cent during the first half of 2025, reaching 2,347 euros per transaction, according to its latest supervisory report.

Banks’ campaigns urging customers to take steps are becoming increasingly intensive. Abanca makes this clear in one of its latest emails to customers on this subject: “We devote a great deal of effort and resources to protecting your money and your data, but we cannot do everything for you. You can prevent online fraud,” it states at the end of the email, with the subject line A new priority: protecting your data. “In reality, banks are fortifying themselves against this new situation,” explains another industry source.

As for time limits, customers have 13 months from the date of the charge to report an unauthorised transaction; the bank has 15 working days to respond to the complaint, and from that response, customers have one year to take the matter to the Bank of Spain. And the key point is that the right to take legal action lapses after five years. Carol Rodríguez, Director of Financial Regulation at finReg360, points out that the CJEU ruling “reinforces that are still pending, but does not automatically reopen proceedings that have already become final”. “Customers who were refused a refund on the grounds of alleged gross negligence could resubmit their claim, provided that the legal requirements are met and the applicable time limits have not expired,” she adds.

Gross negligence

The judgement of 15 October settles the case of a customer of a Polish bank who was contacted by a fraudster posing as a buyer of an item she had previously put up for sale on an online platform. He sent her a link leading to a website that mimicked her bank’s site, where the victim entered her online banking details. The fraudster transferred around 700 euros to his own account. The customer notified the bank the following day, but the bank refused to refund the money, arguing that the victim had breached her “duty to safeguard her payment instrument with due care and not to make it available to unauthorised persons”, according to the ruling.

Until now, financial institutions to refuse to reimburse money lost as a result of fraud. The finReg360 expert explains that “the allegation of gross negligence on the part of the customer has been one of the arguments used by financial institutions and payment service providers to refuse reimbursement for unauthorised transactions”. Now the bank must first refund the money and then, if it considers that the customer was grossly negligent, prove this in order to reclaim the money. The firm’s Director of Financial Regulation adds that in Spain “the Supreme Court (...) reiterated that it is up to the institutions to prove the customer’s gross negligence and that the use of their credentials or strong authentication mechanisms is not, in itself, sufficient to demonstrate it”. The CJEU has dismantled any arguments put forward by financial institutions.

From now on, to customer liability are likely to increase, according to finReg360, although it also anticipates the introduction of measures to mitigate the impact. Specifically, this involves reviewing internal policies and procedures, contractual clauses, as well as criteria for investigating and preserving evidence.

Telecoms and tech firms

Financial sources argue that prevention cannot rest solely with the banks, because is perpetrated outside the banking sector, via telephone calls, text messages, emails or digital platforms that criminals use to impersonate others and deceive customers. They therefore argue that prevention obligations must be extended to all parties involved in the fraud chain.

Brussels has already begun to move in this direction. The future European Payment Services Regulation provides for collaboration between companies and extends preventative requirements to technology firms and telecoms operators. The aim is for companies with the capacity to detect or prevent a fraud to intervene before fraudsters steal the money.

Spain has also taken steps in this direction. Telecoms operators are and messages that use manipulated numbers to impersonate the bank. Added to this is the Alias Register managed by the National Commission for Markets and Competition (), designed to prevent criminals from using identifiers such as a bank’s name to impersonate it in text messages. Financial sources argue that these developments support a model in which banks, telecoms operators and major tech firms share the responsibility for preventing fraud.

[Read More]

Source: Cinco Días

https://cincodias.elpais.com/mercados-financieros/2026-10-22/la-banca-afronta-una-factura-milmillonaria-al-tener-que-devolver-el-dinero-a-sus-clientes-victimas-de-fraude.html?utm_source=chatgpt.com

reCAPTCHA protection